Grell Sutcliffe alternates between making this troper laugh out loud and making her uncomfortable in ways she didn't realize were possible...it's gotta be the fact that he refers to himself as a woman.
What about the almost dual-personality nature of the shift he undergoes when he reveals himself to be half of Jack the Ripper?
Or the way he's constantly sighing and making romantic allusions and practically moaning every time he talks to, near, or about Sebastian? As a Shinigami, anyway.
Uh, sorry, but Grell the BUTLER was a mainline feed to my fetish for adorable, clumsy men who just try way too hard.
Grell Sutcliffe is major fetish fuel for this troper. Glasses, long hair, a suit, slender, the blurring of gender lines, effeminate face that can look creepy at the same time, a persona shift that borders on MPD, Shakespeare aficionado...he made this troper realize that she has sort of a thing for blood as well. * blushes and shuts up before she gets carried away*
The Undertaker's voice in the anime literally made me shudder. In a good way.
You're not the only one. You and I are two of the few willing to admit it.
Fourthed! Damn right, it's hot!
A voice of dissent appears! Normally I'd be all over something like that, but unless I've forgotten something, Beast is an amputee with prosthetic legs. That in itself isn't a problem; its the fact that I have a good friend with the same equipment, and she can't wear stockings, because the joint between her prosthetic and her actual leg tears the material. Because of my ocd, I can't look at Beast without wincing. Fridge Logic actually managed to ruin a piece of Fetish Fuel Unleaded for me.
The second season gives us Alois and his butler Claude. Your Mileage May Vary with Alois though. Some people find him too creepy and rude to be fetish fuel.
Oh no, the creepy just makes him sexier.
This series is perfect for you if you're a Yaoi Fangirl, what with all that Ho Yay and the girly Bishonen.
Taken Beyond The Impossible in episode 20, which features Sebastian chained to the wall being whipped by an angel decked out in S&M gear and describing the excruciating sweetness of the pain being inflicted upon him. Good Lord.
Alois might be this for some. Alternates between being Ax Crazy and cute and innocent at the drop of a hat, flamboyant, Depraved Homosexual, wears booty shorts, wears Grade A Zettai Ryouiki with high-heeled laced up boots on top of that, is a bit effeminate facial wise, displays his contract mark on his tongue, licks a set of chess pieces in the opening sequence, wears a dark purple frock coat, likes to cross-dress, and is a bit of a flirt. Also, the camera likes to focus on his tongue and mouth a lot.
This troper is a big fan of Madame Red. The sassiness, the outfits, that red hair and cut, she's a doctor, her Broken Bird-ness... but not her slasher-ness as I still retain a sense of self-preservation. Shame she wouldn't like me though as I am female and alive.
This female troper is wondering why no one has mentioned Meirin/Mei-Rin/Maylene yet. She's a meganekko and a dojikko AND a meido. And she has pink hair, though it's considered dark red by some.
There's also the fact that she apparently doesn't wear a bra or underwear under her outfit (which leads to an...interesting realization when you take into the account that her body is a Hammerspace, but YMMV). And before we found out she was using it to store Alois's eye, tell me you didn't have suspicious inklings when she knelt down by Ciel and opened her mouth.
Oh, and NOW it turns out she used to be quiteStripperific in her days before serving Alois, and apparently did nothing but lounge around having the Bishonen demon triplets wait on her and comb her hair. Nnnnargh.
Hell, the sheer amount of licking that goes on throughout season 2 keeps making this troper rather...squiggly. Seriously, Alois, Claude, Sebastian licking his lips in preparation to take Ciel's soul, Hannah, and just the sheer amount of focus everyone's mouth gets in this series is almost enough to kill me.
The introduction of Nina Hopkins in chapter 37. Beautiful, eccentric personality, appears to be bisexual, that cute ponytail she wears on the side of her head, the jaunty hat, the Stripperiffic clothing complete with a tear away skirt (with shorts underneath) and garters, and wears glasses? *fans self*
The numerous Ship Tease moments between Sebastian and Ciel, and how Sebastian always carries Ciel bridal style.
Alois cross-dressing in episode 5 and perhaps, for some, how he caresses Ciel's face, looks deep into Ciel's eye, says he wants to be "one with" Ciel, and licks Ciel's ear.
Speaking of Elizabeth, yes she can be annoying and most of the fandom probably considers her a Damsel Scrappy and hates her for getting in the way of Ciel/Sebastian, but I find her to be incredibly cute. She's so sweet, adorable, likes cute things, and looks like a little doll.
In the Ciel In Wonderland OVA she gets turned into a giantess.
Timber, Thompson, and Cantebury, from the second season. Three demon Bishonen who look like Sebastian's love child except with purple hair, are skilled battle butlers, quiet, and triplets. Yes please.
Judging by the official art of the outfits for the upcoming Ciel in Wonderland OVA, there's bound to be tons of Fetish Fuel for everyone.
Lizzy gets turned into a giantess.
Ciel cross-dresses again.
Pluto licking Sebastian's face, oddly enough...
Pluto himself. He can alternate between being either a naked Bishonen or a huge dog, wears a collar, later gets a nice suit to wear, and is very attached to Sebastian.
It's like the shinigami were created to be walking fanservice. Glasses, suits, sharp pointy weapons are like toys to them, even their personalities (Grelle's insane, William's strict stoicism, and Ronald's laid-back flirt) and not forgetting their association with death...I need a moment. And their voices. William's, Grelle's and ESPECIALLY Ronald's, Undertaker's too, if you use the anime canon. And let's not forget just how surprisingly good Grelle looks drenched in blood...the others probably wouldn't look too bad, either.
I know his voice was listed above, but The Undertaker in general. He's just unsettling enough, obviously has a sense of humor to him, quite knowledgeable... The fact that he could have a thing for his customers might deter this troper if she wasn't such a Nightmare Fetishist.
For this troper, seeing Sebastian hurt, confused, or otherwise losing his composure has a very pleasant squiggly effect.
We went this far without mentioning Ciel's sleepwear? The guy wears a big poofy white shirt to bed. And only a big poofy white shirt. And Sebastian dresses him every morning (NOTE: this fudanshi troper doesn't ship Ciel/Sebastian, he just figured that it had to be brought up).